The legal framework for SEP disputes in the EU post-Huawei: whither harmonization?

Zingales, Nicolo (2017) The legal framework for SEP disputes in the EU post-Huawei: whither harmonization? Yearbook of European Law, 36. pp. 628-682. ISSN 0263-3264

[img] PDF - Accepted Version
Restricted to SRO admin only until 18 December 2019.

Download (862kB)


This article revisits the antitrust treatment of unilateral conduct in Standard Essential Patent (SEP) disputes in the EU, with particular focus on the landmark CJEU judgment in Huawei v ZTE and the way it has affected subsequent developments before national courts. It explains that while the court in Huawei significantly improved legal certainty both for SEP holders and their potential licensees, it also left open a number of crucial questions affecting everyday licensing practice. First, it is not entirely clear whether the liability of an SEP holder presupposes leveraging by a vertically integrated firm or can also arise in purely vertical or horizontal relationships. Secondly, the safe harbour procedure formu- lated in the judgment begs important questions concerning burden of proof and portfolio licensing, which have given rise to divergent interpretations. It follows that the space remains wide open for competing national and even regional approaches to the rights and obligations of SEP holders, calling for further European harmonization—be it judicially, legislatively, or administratively through the European Commission. In support of the latter measures, the article illustrates the limited remit of EU private international law rules in preventing the forum shopping which is likely to unfold as a result of a fragmented landscape for the resolution of SEP disputes, and the limited ability of the Unified Patent Court to ameliorate the associated fragmentation a.nd coordination problems.

Item Type: Article
Keywords: Standard Essential Patents; injunctions; Huawei v ZTE; forum shopping; Recast Regulation
Schools and Departments: School of Law, Politics and Sociology > Law
Depositing User: Nicolo Zingales
Date Deposited: 26 Feb 2018 11:28
Last Modified: 26 Feb 2018 12:32

View download statistics for this item

📧 Request an update